I
am living out my adolescent dream of travel and adventure.
Tim
Cahill
Hunting Fairburns, summer 1966.
I recently had the opportunity to hit the road on my
annual two-week fall camping trip to the Black Hills of South Dakota. Most readers certainly realize that I “fell
in love with” the Hills during my academic stay at the University of South
Dakota from 1965-67. My Blog postings
feature South Dakota more than any other state as I continue to explore the
fascinating geology and physiography—along with brew pubs, coffee shops and
non-chain eating establishments. My
major discovery this year was a small coffee shop located in a used book store
in Douglas, Wyoming. Wow, what a treat
to find such a locality “on the road.”
An earlier summer trip to the northern Hills is
documented in postings on August 9, 2017.
This fall trip took us back to the southern Hills with headquarters in
Custer State Park at Legion Lake Campground.
This location gives me a chance to: visit collecting sites east of the
Hills to explore for Fairburn Agates; pound on the limestone at Teepee Canyon collecting
the parental site of the Fairburns; explore garnet localities west of Custer;
pan for a little gold near George Custer’s camp sites on French Creek; visit
the great rock and mineral stores in Custer, Hill City and Keystone; and relive
my past geology adventures and travel (see Post October 15, 2017). The latter are often enhanced by an aging
brain!
Study
what you love, and you’ll never have to work a day in your life. It’ll be one great adventure.
David
Gerrold
 |
| Pounding on the rocks at Teepee Canyon. |
I can’t say that the limestone at Teepee Canyon
produced any magnificent specimens this year; however, the joy of being alone
and pounding away was certainly worth the trip.
For new Blog readers, the quarries at Teepee Canyon, and other nearby
localities, produce chert nodules from the late Paleozoic Minnelusa Formation;
some of the chert is “agatized” with holly leaf fortification agates. The Minnelusa
is described as “Light-brown to red and gray sandstone, solution breccia,
limestone and shale [that is] Lower Permian and Pennsylvanian {in age] (DeWitt
and others, 1989). In past years these agates from the Minnelusa were called “limestone
agates” and most collectors were adamantly opposed to any relationship between
limestone agates in the Hills and the Fairburn agates from the surrounding
plains. However, Roger Clark has constructed
a detailed study of the Minnelusa--Fairburn relationship and any collector
interested in Fairburn agates should read his book (Clark, 2009)---and the
agate photographs are spectacular.
 |
Teepee Canyon. Width photo ~6 cm.
|
 |
| Teepee Canyon. Width photo ~4.4 cm. |
 |
| Teepee Canyon. Width photo ~3 cm. |
 |
| Teepee Canyon. Width photo ~3 cm. |
 |
Teepee Canyon. Width photo ~2.7 cm.
|
Another agate that crossed my knowledge path somewhere
in the past was called the State Park Agate
(sometimes Game Lodge Agates) and referred to agates collected in Custer
State Park near the Game Lodge. Clark
(2009) refers to these specimens as limestone agates since their source was
also the Minnelusa Formation. Since rock
and mineral collecting is not allowed in the Park, any of these agates on display
or for sale evidently were collected years in the past. This year I happened to spot a tray of Park
Agates for sale in a Custer rock and mineral shop—Ken’s Minerals. According to the clerk, the original owner of
the shop (opened 1936), Kenneth Spring, Sr., picked up these Park Agates decades
ago when collecting was legal. So, I
purchased a single specimen for my collection.
 |
| State Park agate. Width photo ~ 9 mm. |
I previously reported (October 7, 2017) on the Pringle
Agates, also limestone agates and probably from the Minnelusa. According to local shopkeepers the Pringle
Agates always appear to be “bleached.” I
don’t know if that is true since I have seen very few agates attributed to the Pringle
area. However, my single specimen is
certainly “washed out.”
 |
A
"limestone agate" locally named Pringle Agates likely eroded from the
Minnelusa Formation near Pringle, south of Custer. Width ~2.7 cm.
|
So, now it was out to the plains east of the town of
Fairburn for collecting at the original Fairburn beds. I experienced “luck” at these beds in past
years going all the way back to summer 1966.
This year I picked up a pretty poor one (a few faint lines on the
jasper), a second specimen that is small but with nice lines, and finally a
third that a friend trimmed, stuck in a tumbler and turned out a decent
agate. But perhaps the most exciting
find was a silicified fossil (where silica had replaced the original calcite
hard parts) known as Chaetetes
milleparacedus. The chaetetids were long thought to be a type
of tabulate coral where their long, slender tubes contained tabulae or cross
partitions (Phylum Cnidaria). However,
studies in the 1980s determined the chaetetids were a type of sponge (Phylum
Porifera). Chaetetids are very
diagnostic animals, easy to identify and became extinct at the end of the
middle Pennsylvanian (~307 Ma.)
 |
Fairburn Agate collected in the rough and then subjected to trim, grinding, polishing and a tumbler. Width ~3.3 cm.
|
 |
| Fairburn Agate collected "in the rough." Width ~ 8 mm. |
 |
Side (top) and cross sectional view (bottom) of a stylized specimen of Chaetetes. Courtesy of University of South Florida, http://etc.usf.edu/clipart/
|
 |
Silicified and well-rounded specimen of Chaetetes milleparacedus collected in the Fairburn Agate beds. Width ~ 4.5 cm.
|
The Minnelusa contains a diagnostic invertebrate fauna
and silicified fossil shells sometimes appear with the Fairburn Agates out on
the plains (Clark, 2009). In fact, in
2014 I collected a fossil brachiopod and reported on the creature in a posting
on October 7, 2014. Whatever the case,
Fairburns or no Fairburns, the beds are a place for relaxation just trekking
around and noting the wild looking scenery.
Wandering I do.
A mile or so south of Custer, along the highway to Pringle (US 385), I
was poking around in the roadside ditch looking for tourmaline (schorl) when I
picked up a small piece of granite/pegmatite holding some larger garnets. The dodecahedrons seem likely to be
spessartines (manganese aluminum silicate) since they are black or dark brown
in color and appear not to have a hint of red.
Of course, my mineralogy might be a little suspect and perhaps they are
the iron aluminum silicate, almandine.
 |
Garnets, spessartine?, collected south of Custer. Largest individual has a width of ~1.2 cm.
|
A couple of years ago a collector from Custer kindly
gave me a quantity of rock from the Bull Moose Mine (~ 3 miles southeast of
Custer city) with instructions to break it open and try to find small phosphate
minerals. Periodically I drag out the
matrix and pound away. This fall, on a
slow night in October, I cracked open a bundle of pyrite crystals and discovered
some beautiful lilac to and clear crystals of a phosphate. Now, the problem arises—were the crystals
phosphosiderite (AKA metastrengite), FePO4-2H2O,
or strengite, FePO4-2H2O?
Yes, that’s correct---both minerals have the same chemical formula, a
hydrated iron phosphate. Phosphosiderite
(Monoclinic) and strengite (Orthorhombic) are dimorphous minerals, that is they
have the same chemical composition but belong to different crystal systems. And
at the Bull Moose Mine, the two are difficult to distinguish; however, Tom
Loomis at Dakota Matrix Minerals (www.dakotamatrix.com), the Black Hills guru
of phosphate minerals, noted that phosphosiderite shows striations parallel to
the long C crystallographic axis. Since
I am able to identify the striations, I am calling these neat little crystals phosphosiderite.
 |
Photomicrograph
of lilac-colored elongated crystals of phosphosiderite collected from
the Bull Moose Mine. Width of specimen at bottom of photo is ~ 1.1 cm
|
 |
Phosphosiderite
is exposed on a flat surface on right side of photo and indicated by a P
and arrow. Most of the specimen is pyrite, Py, with minor barbosalite,
B. Total width of specimen ~3.3 cm.
|
Phosphosiderite is a secondary mineral produced when
primary minerals containing phosphate oxidize and the ferrous iron (Fe++)
moves to ferric iron (Fe+++).
Notice above that the phosphate ion (PO4- - -) in
phosphosiderite has in minus 3 charge and balances the Fe+++ Tom
Loomis. over at Dakota Matrix. noted “triphylite is the primary phase [the
primary phosphate mineral] which is very susceptible to hydrothermal oxidation
and is the host for most of the secondary phosphates [such as phosphosiderite]
from the Tip Top and many other pegmatites [such as the Bull Moose]. Triphylite, Li+Fe++PO4-
- -, contains ferrous iron with a plus two charge, and lithium with a
plus 1charge as they balance the minus 3 charge of the phosphate. Upon
oxidation the ferrous iron moves to ferric iron as the lithium leaches away.
I also have a second specimen from the Bull Moose
purchased from a rock and mineral shop in Hill City and labeled
phosphosiderite. However, I suspect it
is strengite and another iron phosphate, barbosalite, Fe++Fe+++2(PO4)2(OH)2
.
 |
Photomicrograph
(above) with stringers and"balls" of strengite; however, there are two
color patterns present and it may be a mixture of the dimorphs strengite
and phosphosiderite. The bottom photos indicates the position of the
strengite in massive barbosalite. The ? is an unknown mineral, at least
to me.
|
Pyrrhotite is a common mineral in the Homestake Mine of
the northern Black Hills and an iron sulfide (Fe7S8 as
listed in MinDat.org); however, it seems to have a variable amount of iron present
(Klein, 2002) and is often listed as Fe1-XS. Pure iron sulfide (FeS
where x in the formula is 0---50 atomic percent iron) is a mineral called
troilite that is quite rare on Earth but seems common in meteorites. There
seems to be a complete solid solution between troilite and “typical” pyrrhotite
where x in the formula is .2---44.9 atomic percent iron (Klein, 2002). That indicates the pyrrhotite has about 20%
vacancy of iron in the crystal structure.
For reasons that seem unclear to my mineralogical mind, troilite is
non-magnetic while pyrrhotite is magnetic.
Perhaps not as much as magnetite but never-the-less, magnetic, and
easily attracted to a magnet. In the
solid solution series, the magnetism then varies with the iron deficiency (more
iron, less magnetism) but if heated to ~320OC all magnetism
disappears.
 |
Pyrrhotite and quartz from the Homestake Mine. Total width ~3 cm.
|
Nice crystals of pyrrhotite are brassy to a dark brown
in color. They have a metallic luster
and an almost black streak on unglazed porcelain. Hardness seems to range on either side of 4
(Mohs). However, this specimen I picked
up at a rock shop in Hill City contains massive pyrrhotite and is labeled: Pyrhotite (sic) collected on the Rocky Mtn
GSA field trip 4/3/60 3650” level, Homestake mine Lead, South Dakota. Unfortunately, the collector is not
identified. Interestingly this specimen was collected nearly 60 years ago!
Roberts and Rapp (1965) stated “pyrrhotite is one of
the most abundant and most characteristic ore minerals of the Homestake
Mine. It is never found in crystals, but
occurs in irregular, vermicular masses…”
I also picked up a mounted specimen (Perky Box) of
galena and calcite cubes labeled Homestake Mine 1961. I nabbed on to this due:
1) to the older date; and 2) to my memory believing galena was somewhat scarce
at Homestake. Galena is listed on
MinDat.org as being present; however, photos are not shown. Roberts and Rapp (1963) noted only the
presence of small cubic crystals, <1mm, in a vug.
 |
Galena and calcite from Homestake Mine. Total width of specimen ~2.4 cm.
|
Another specimen of cubic galena was purchased and
labeled as collected from the Double Rainbow Mine near the settlement of Galena
in the northern Black Hills. I love the
connection between the mineral and the settlement although the pay zone was
silver. As with many gold/silver/lead
prospects in the northern Black Hills, the mineralizing fluids are associated
with the Tertiary intrusives---with metal formation in the bedding planes,
cracks, crevices and vugs of the Cambrian Deadwood Formation. The intrusives at Galena are composed of
numerous sills and dikes that contain a wide variety of rocks with a
fine-grained groundmass sprinkled with feldspar phenocrysts. Check out the Blog Posting on October 22,
2016.
 |
Galena and sphalerite from Double Rainbow Mine. Total width ~3.0 cm.
|
Finally, in a previous posting (October 7, 2016) I
detained some accounts of George Custer’s trip to the Black Hills in 1874 and
his “discovery” of gold on French Creek near the town of Custer. In that post I noted that a flake or two of
gold was still available to “wannabe gold panners.” Well, the take was a little better this year! I could never “get rich” off panning gold but
do understand how early miners might get “gold fever” when first observing
those tiny flakes.
 |
Several small nuggets panned from Custer County. Width of photo is ~1.0 cm.
|
REFERENCES
CITED
Clark, R., 2009, South Dakota’s state gemstone—Fairburn
Agate: Silverwind Agates, Appleton, Wisconsin.
DeWitt, E., J.A. Redden, D. Buscher, and A.B. Wilson,
1989, Geologic Map of the Black Hills area, South Dakota and Wyoming: U.S.
Geological Survey Miscellaneous Investigation Series Map I-1910.
Klein, C., 2002, The 22nd edition of the Manual of
Mineral Science (after James D. Dana): John Wiley and Sons, Inc.
Lufkin, J.L., J.A. Redden, A. Lisenbee and T. Loomis,
2009, Guidebook to the geology of the Black Hills, South Dakota: Golden
Publishers, Golden, Colorado.
Roberts, W.L. and Rapp, G. Jr., 1965, Mineralogy of
the Black Hills; South Dakota School of Mines and Technology, Bull. 18.
